This review opens with a word, because the word is the product. Wallet of Satoshi is retiring the custodial wallet that made its name, pointing users at a replacement it calls self-custodial. Phoenix, from ACINQ, answers the same question the old way: twelve words, written down, and if you lose them the money is gone. Both put Lightning on a phone. Neither asks you to trust the same people.

Updated 7 November 2026: details are re-sourced to primary documents, and lines with no primary document are cut.

Updated 6 November 2026: the score is removed; this is now an assessment of published documents.

The file on each

First, correct the framing

Wallet of Satoshi has not gone self-custody. Its homepage, as of this writing, still advertises both modes: custodial, where the company holds the keys on your behalf, and self-custodial, where you hold them. What is winding down is the legacy custodial wallet, region by region.

Wallet of Satoshi’s own thread on X, posted 13 August 2026, says creating new invoices from the old custodial wallet is already off in the US, EU, Australia and New Zealand, and that at the end of September the same happens everywhere else. A 30 June 2027 cut-off to move balances appears in press coverage, not in a document the desk read. We read the company’s support index and its 25 August 2026 disclosure document on 3 September and found none of these dates in either — a fact about those two documents, not proof it is unsaid elsewhere. Treat them as a reason to act early, not a contract.

What the replacement actually is

That disclosure document is the useful text. It says that under self-custody Wallet of Satoshi does not hold, access or have the ability to recover your keys. It also names the machinery: Spark, the LightSpark-developed Layer 2 that underpins the self-custody functionality, alongside Flashnet for routing, swaps and settlement, with the company disclaiming responsibility for those third parties’ actions, omissions or modifications, which it says can affect whether the features work.

Both sentences hold at once, and that is the trap. Wallet of Satoshi, per its disclosure, does not hold your key. Somebody else holds a share of one.

The trust that remains

Spark describes a 1-of-n operator model: a Signing Operator co-signs with you, neither side can move funds alone, and the arrangement holds while one operator stays honest. That page still says two operators; Spark’s docs FAQ now names three, adding Breez. Security depends on that operator destroying its old key share after each transfer — and Spark states plainly that operators cannot cryptographically prove key deletion. Its own layer-two comparison goes further: Lightning is fully trustless, with no federation, no operator and no third-party key holders, while Spark trades full trustlessness for usability.

Independent readings agree. Bitcoin Magazine’s October 2025 piece by Seth For Privacy prefers trust-minimized to trustless, and gives the failure case: if every operator refused to delete its key share and colluded with a previous sender, a leaf could be double-spent. Unanimous collusion is a high bar carrying reputational cost. It is not zero, and zero is what self-custody promises. On the July 2025 announcement, developer Matt Corallo said the label fully trusts the operator not to steal; Spark’s CTO Kevin Hurley answered that operators delete keys once transfers complete.

Phoenix’s answer

Phoenix does not have this problem, and pays for the privilege. ACINQ’s repository states the wallet is self-custodial, that a 12-word phrase is generated at setup, that only you have it, and that losing it loses your funds. No operator’s good behaviour to rely on, no deletion promise to audit. And Phoenix keeps a real Lightning channel per user — ACINQ’s splicing write-up describes one channel, one UTXO each — which costs on-chain fees to fund and resize.

Our assessment

This is an assessment of published documents, not of using either wallet: Wallet of Satoshi’s self-custodial mode is described as built on a Spark layer whose operators must delete old key shares they cannot prove they deleted, so the word self-custody carries residual trust, while Phoenix is described as twelve words and no other party, with channel fees as the price. Read the disclosure and Spark’s own documents before moving a balance.

If the amount is small and the point is spending — coffee, tips, a Lightning address — the Spark-based wallet is a reasonable home, provided you read the word as trust-minimized rather than trustless. If the balance is one you would grieve, Phoenix is the stronger answer, and the rival vendor says as much.

The briefing does not change with the app. The recovery phrase goes on paper or metal, offline: never typed into a keyboard, never photographed, never stored in a cloud, never given to support. Moving a custodial balance, send a test amount first. Set it against where your seed comes from on a hardware device, because the same phrase governs both. Crypto assets are high risk, and self-custody moves that risk onto your desk — so read the disclosure and Spark’s research pages yourself, then pick the failure mode you can live with.

Documents read

Read on 6 November 2026:

  • Wallet of Satoshi Disclosure Document v1.23, 25 Aug 2026: Self-custody available globally, WoS does not hold, access or recover keys; custodial in select regions; Spark is the third-party LightSpark Layer 2 underpinning self-custody.

  • Spark docs FAQ: Spark’s founding operators are Lightspark, Flashnet and Breez.

  • ACINQ Phoenix README: Phoenix is a self-custodial Bitcoin wallet; a 12-word recovery phrase is generated, only you have it, and if you lose it your funds are lost.

  • Spark research article: Two-of-two key model with operators holding the other key by threshold signing; security depends on operators destroying old key shares; exit to L1 without permission.

  • Wallet of Satoshi thread on X, 13 Aug 2026: Company says the custodial wallet is being retired gradually; creating new invoices already off in US, EU, Australia, NZ; same at end of September everywhere else; existi.

  • Phoenix Wallet, US App Store: Free app, category Finance, developer ACINQ.